“Gear Craver is reader supported. We may make a small commission at no extra cost to you should you make a purchase through links from this site.”

The Most Comfortable Bike Seat For Overweight Riders Helpful Guide

most comfortable bike seat for overweight riders

Like many of you, I’m not the lightest weight person out there. Bike makers all seem to put very narrow seats with minimal padding. These aren’t that comfortable for most riders. Biking is a great way to lose weight but you need a comfortable bike seat to keep getting back on that bike day after day. What is the most comfortable bike seat for overweight riders?

Fortunately, there are tons of bike seats available to put on your bike that are much more comfortable. Finding the right seat will make riding your bike much more enjoyable. That will make you want to ride it more. Biking is my main exercise and I’ve had great success with weight loss from it. Let’s help you find the most comfortable bike seat for you so you can get out and enjoy biking.

Below are our top picks for most comfortable bike seat for overweight bikers. See below for our helpful guide, reviews and FAQ.

Top Pick

Giddy Up! Bike Seat

Editors Choice

Wittkop Bicycle Saddle

Best Value

BLUEWIND Bike Seat

The Top 5 Best Most Comfortable Bike Seat For Overweight Cyclists

Top Pick

Giddy Up! Bike Seat

  • PREMIUM COMPLETE BUNDLE —- BIKE SEAT WITH TAIL LIGHT, BIKE SEAT, COVER, REFLECTIVE BAND and MOUNTING WRENCH
  • SHOCK ABSORBING BALL, MEMORY FOAM MATERIAL and WATERPROOF
  • YOUR SAFETY COMES FIRST —- Giddy Up! Bike seat comes with a LED TAIL LIGHT and a REFLECTIVE BAND

Summary

The Giddy Up! Bike Seat is designed to be one of the most comfortable bike seats on the market. It has generous width at 8.3 inches. It has dual rubber ball suspension in the seat frame. It uses memory foam for padding. The foam has adequate support. Some riders felt that the seat felt a little on the stiff side.

The seat comes as a complete package including the seat, assembly tools, an LED taillight, and a seat cover. The seat is a good value and comfortable for overweight cyclists. This makes it our top pick for best most comfortable bike seat for overweight riders.

Specifications

  • Seat Width – 8.3inches
  • Seat Length – 11inches
  • Padding – Memory foam
  • Max rider weight – 300lbs+
What We Liked
✔️ Shock Absorbing balls and memory foam padding
✔️ Includes a tail light
✔️ Complete package including install tools and seat cover
What We Didn’t Like
Some people received broken lights
Some users find the seat a little too stiff

Editor’s Choice

Wittkop City Bicycle Saddle

  • 𝗛𝗜𝗚𝗛-𝗤𝗨𝗔𝗟𝗜𝗧𝗬 𝗠𝗘𝗠𝗢𝗥𝗬 𝗙𝗢𝗔𝗠 – The special foam layer of the saddle clings perfectly to your body
  • 𝗜𝗡𝗡𝗢𝗩𝗔𝗧𝗜𝗩𝗘 𝟱-𝗭𝗢𝗡𝗘-𝗖𝗢𝗡𝗖𝗘𝗣𝗧 – The unisex bike seat is partitioned into five individually conceptualized zones.
  • 𝗘𝗡𝗛𝗔𝗡𝗖𝗘𝗗 𝗔𝗜𝗥𝗙𝗟𝗢𝗪-𝗦𝗬𝗦𝗧𝗘𝗠 – The internal braces of the Wittkop saddle guarantee an innovative air ventilation

Summary

The Wittkop City Bicycle Saddle is a well made bike seat from an long time established brand. Wittkop has been making bike saddles since 1898. The City Saddle is their widest design with the most padding. It uses memory foam and has 5 design zones with different stiffness. The center of the seat has an airflow channel to keep moisture out and also to relieve pressure on the perineum.

Most users thought the saddle was very comfortable. A few thought it was too stiff and the nose was too wide. Overall it is a very comfortable saddle and my choice for best most comfortable bike seat for overweight cyclists.

Specifications

  • Seat Width – 8.5inches
  • Seat Length – 10inches
  • Padding – Memory foam
  • Max rider weight – Not specified
What We Liked
✔️ Very comfortable for heavy riders
✔️ Airflow through seat
✔️ 5 zone padding design
What We Didn’t Like
Can be difficult to tighten onto seat post
The nose of the seat is too wide for some people

Best Value

BLUEWIND Bike Seat

  • BLUEWIND Red Wide Mountain Bike Seat – Super comfortable high density memory foam
  • Ergonomic Design – The front part is smooth and a half inch narrower than normal bicycle seat, so it will not rub
  • Extra Shockproof & Noiseless – Double Anti-vibration rubber ball, good elasticity, flexibility, and toughness

Summary

The BLUEWIND Bike Seat is a great low cost comfort bike seat. It uses memory foam and shock absorbing balls to attach the frame. The seat has adequate memory foam padding for most riders. The seat uses a fake leather for the covering that isn’t very breathable and absorbs water. The seat can become a bit spongy on long rides.

The foam and shock absorbers are great for shorter rides. For longer rides, the lack of breathability and the foam packing out make it not that comfortable.

This seat from Bluewind is a a value priced seat and a good choice for heavier bike riders looking for a low cost comfort seat.

Specifications

  • Seat Width – 8.3inches
  • Seat Length – 10.4inches
  • Padding – Memory foam
  • Max rider weight – 250 lbs+
What We Liked
✔️ Dual shock absorbing spring balls
✔️ Ergonomic design with a narrower nose
✔️ Good comfort and shock absorption
What We Didn’t Like
Durability of leather cover
Universal mount doesn’t work with all seat post diameters

Most Comfortable Bike Seat For Women

Bikeroo Womens Bike Saddle

  • COMFORTABLE BIKE SADDLE – Bikeroo bicycle saddle is considered one of the most comfortable bike seat
  • BEST USE FOR WOMEN – The wider saddle design makes sure that its best suited for the a girls anatomy
  • GREAT REPLACEMENT BIKE SEAT – Upgrading your bike saddle is a great investment that makes all the difference

Summary

The Bikeroo Womens Bike Saddle is anatomically shaped for woman’s bodies. It has a center cutout and channel to relieve pressure on your feminine parts. The seat has adequate foam padding and width to be comfortable for biking.

The seat mounting adapter works okay for most installations. It can be challenging to adjust the angle of the seat. The seat angle is critical to getting good comfort out of the bike seat.

Riders enjoyed using this with comfort and hybrid bikes. It was much cushier than the narrow hard seats that come with a new bike. This is our best pick for most comfortable bike seat for woman

Specifications

  • Seat Width – 7.8inches
  • Seat Length – 10.2inches
  • Padding – Soft foam
  • Max rider weight – Not specified
What We Liked
✔️ Dual spring suspension
✔️ Shaped for women’s anatomy
✔️ Extra thick soft padding
What We Didn’t Like
Seat angle is difficult to adjust
Not enough padding for some users

Best Bicycle Seat For 300 Pound Men Or Women

Planet Bike Comfort Tractor Bike seat

  • Elastomer spring suspension for shock absorption
  • Foam padding for ultimate comfort
  • Extra Wide profile design to maximize support area

Summary

The Planet Bike Comfort Tractor Bike seat is one of the best seats out there for riders over 300 lbs. It has extra width for support. The spring and elastomer suspension does a great job of supporting heavier riders.

The seat is very durable and holds up well to lots of riding by bigger people. There have been few issues with rails, seat wings, or molding braking.

This seat does not include any kind of universal seat mounting adapter. It has standard rails that will fit onto most existing bike seat posts that use rail mounts.

This is our best pick for most comfortable bike seat for men and women over 300 lbs.

Specifications

  • Seat Width – 10.6inches
  • Seat Length – 11.0inches
  • Padding – Foam
  • Max rider weight – 400 lbs
What We Liked
✔️ Extra wide width
✔️ Elastomer spring suspension
✔️ Good for at least 400 lb person
What We Didn’t Like
Covers not available for this seat
Doesn’t include any seat mount adapters

The truth about bike seats

Bike seats are not a wide size fits all problem. Everyone has different width and shape to their sit bones. Everyone has different riding styles. A bike seat for someone riding short trips around town will be very different from a bike seat for someone riding 3 hour long mountain bike rides. What is comfortable for someone else may not be comfortable for you.

The more you ride, the more your butt tissue hardens up and the soreness of sitting on a bike will go away. The more you ride, the better it feels and the more fun it gets. A new seat can help but it won’t do everything. Don’t be afraid to try out a few different seats to find what you really like.

Why is my bike seat uncomfortable

Bike seat discomfort comes from 2 main sources. Sit bone sourness and chafing in the crotch area. To solve the first problem you need to find a bicycle seat that is the correct width for your sit bones. You don’t want your seat to be too narrow or your sit bones won’t rest on it. Your bike seat needs to be adjusted so it is in the correct position for you. To learn more about seat positioning click here.

The second problem, chafing results from having a seat that is too wide. For short duration rides this isn’t a problem since you don’t have time to chafe down there. For long duration rides of more than an hour this becomes much more of a problem.

Extra wide seats with lots of padding are great for rides up to an hour long. For bike rides longer than an hour, those narrow, uncomfortable looking, bike seats starting getting a lot more comfortable.

The below video gives some information on positioning your bike seat and bike seat widths.

Why do my sit bones hurt when cycling

The simple answer is that your sit bones hurt because there is too much pressure in the soft tissue and not the bones. This can be from a seat that is too narrow so the weight isn’t supported by the bone. This can also be from a seat with too much padding. Your bouncing around too much in the padding and weight isn’t resting on the bones.

The more you bike, the more the soft tissue in that area hardens up and you will hurt less. The first few weeks to a month of cycling in the spring just never feels great. After a winter of not biking, all your butt tissue is softened up.

Some soreness when you start biking is natural and it gets better with more hours spent on the bike. Changing bike seats can help. Changing seats won’t work a miracle.

Is a wide bike seat more comfortable

For shorter bike rides that are an hour or less, a wider bike seat with more padding will be more comfortable. Chafing problems caused by wide seats and too much padding won’t show up until you start doing longer rides. If you are regularly riding for an hour or more, your tissue around your sitbones is hardened up. This means you can probably tolerate a narrow, stiff bike seat.

How do I know what width bike saddle to buy?

Bike shops have devices for measuring your sit bones. This can help you make sure you get a wide enough bike seat. Most humans have sit bone widths between 100mm and 150mm or 4 to 6 inches. Any seat wider than 6.5 inches will contain the sit bones of almost any human alive.

This measurement only becomes important if you are buying a narrow bike. Narrow bike seats are best for long duration rides and high performance riding.

For more information on sit bone measurement and seat sizing see the video below.

large bikers riding on path

Bike Seat FAQ

Q: What is a good bicycle for an overweight person?

Any bike can be a good bike for an overweight person. The easiest bikes to ride are mountain bikes and hybrid bikes. These bikes have straight handlebars and upright seating positions making them more stable and easier to ride. The wider tires on mountain bikes and hybrid bikes make the ride smoother and also make the bike easier to balance. Click here to see my guide on under $600 mountain bikes.

If you really have difficulty balancing on a bicycle due to your weight, there are also tricycle bikes. These have 2 rear wheels so balance is never an issue. These are great for people who can’t ride a regular bicycle.

Another great invention of the past few years is the pedal assist electric bike. These bikes have electric motors that assist you in pedaling the bike. These bikes are wonderful for people who had leg, knee, hip, ankle, or foot injuries that made pedaling hard. I know several people who can now bike again because of these. They are just as good for exercise and weight loss as a normal bike. You still have to pedal to make them go. Pedaling isn’t as hard as it normally is.

Q: Can an overweight person ride a bike?

Yes. An overweight person can still ride a bike. Mountain bikes with lower gearing, pedal assist electric bikes or trike bikes all can allow someone with health issues to bike. Bikes can handle big people. One of my best riding friends is a 6.5 foot over 300 lb person and his mountain bike can take it.

Q: How can I make my bike seat more comfortable?

The best but most unpopular answer to this question is ride the bike more. The more you ride, the tougher the skin and tissues surrounding your sit bones will become. Biking will become less sore and more comfortable.

If you want to try and make your existing seat more comfortable because you can’t bear it and you don’t want a new seat, there is an answer. Try a seat cover that adds more padding to your bike seat. These add another thick layer of foam to your seat increasing the cushiness of it.

Bikeroo Large Bike Seat Cushion

  • DONT LET THE PAIN GET IN YOUR TRACK – This cover is perfect to be used as a comfy beach gel seat cover
  • EVERYTHING YOU NEED TO IMPROVE YOUR CYCLING SESSIONS – A wide seat gel cushion cover to eliminate pain
  • NO MORE SECOND DAY SORE – Add more padding on your seat by using our Bikeroo ergonomic seat cushion

Q: Why do womens and mens bike seats have holes

The cutout in bike seats helps reduce pressure in your crotch area. This helps increase blood flow and prevent numbness. Genital numbness can be a problem for both male and female cyclists on long bike rides. The holes were added to bike seats to redistribute the pressure and prevent this. A side benefit of the holes is airflow up through the seat helping to keep your crotch dry. To learn more about this problem click here.

bikers looking at sunset

You might also like:

selfie for info block

About the author

My name is Doug Ryan. I am an adventure sports fan and an avid skier, sailor, mountain biker who also enjoys paddle boarding, kayaking, wakeboarding, waterskiing, and travel. I take any chance I can get to get out in the snow or water.  I actively run an adventure sports meetup where I get asked many questions.  I decided to start Gear Craver as a way to share my knowledge and enthusiasm for adventure sports their gear.

Recent biking articles

Leave a Comment